Our Pie Flavors

Featured Cream Pies

5 Layer Butterscotch Pie
Our flaky crust layered with melted butterscotch, cinnamon meringue, whipped cream and butterscotch whipped cream. A butterscotch lovers dream pie!!![...]
5 Layer Chocolate Mint Pie
Our flaky crust layered with dark chocolate, mint flavoring, cinnamon meringue, whipped cream and chocolate whipped cream. The 5 Layer[...]
5 Layer Chocolate Pie
Our flaky crust layered with dark chocolate, cinnamon meringue, whipped cream and chocolate whipped cream. Our 5 Layer Chocolate Pie[...]
Banana Cream Pie
**Available for Pick Up Only** Banana Cream Pie can be made "Sugar Free" upon request All pies are made 9"[...]
Butterfinger Pie
The candy bar chocolate and Butterfinger taste you love all packed into one delicious, mouth watering, pie... The Butterfinger Pie[...]
Chocolate Banana Pie
**Available for Pick Up Only* Our traditional Banana Cream pie with a melted chocolate layer on the bottom and chocolate[...]
Coconut Cream Pie
Delicious, fluffy coconut custard cream topped with real whipped cream and toasted coconut. Coconut Cream Pie can be made "Sugar[...]
French Blueberry Pie
**Available for Pick Up Only* This French Blueberry Pie is made on a graham cracker crust with a cream cheese[...]
French Cherry Pie
**Available for Pick Up Only* This French Cherry Pie is made on a graham cracker crust with a cream cheese[...]
French Silk Pie
Our version of traditional French Silk pie, a light chocolate mousse on our homemade crust. Although not as popular as[...]
Key Lime Pie
As good a Key Lime pie as you can get this far from Florida because we use Key Lime juice[...]
Lemon Angel Pie
**Available for Pick Up Only* Lemon Angel Pie is one of our most popular and unique pies. An original from[...]
Orange Chocolate Pie
**Available for Pick Up Only* This is a spinoff of our Lemon Angel Pie and worth a taste! It's a[...]
Toffee Cream Pie
A chocolaty toffee cream filling topped with toffee bits and drizzled with rich chocolate. Toffee Cream Pie cannot be made[...]
Turtle Coconut Pie
Delicious, fluffy coconut custard cream topped with real whipped cream and toasted coconut. Add some Pecans and a drizzle of[...]

Featured Baked Pies

Apple Crunch Pie
Tart, crisp apples and pebbled on top with our delicious oatmeal and brown sugar crunch topping. The Apple Crunch Pie[...]
Apple Strawberry Crunch Pie
Tart, crisp apples and strawberries mixed together to create this tasty pie. Topped with our delicious oatmeal and brown sugar[...]
Blackberry Peach Crunch Pie
A delicious combination of blackberries and peaches topped with our famous oatmeal and brown sugar crunch equals Blackberry Peach Crunch[...]
Blueberry Pie
Our Blueberry Pies is always a Northwoods favorite. Sweet blueberries nestled between two light pastry crusts. Our Blueberry Pie can[...]
Blueberry Crunch Pie
Blueberry Crunch Pie is a delicious combination of sweet blueberries topped with our famous oatmeal and brown sugar crunch topping.[...]
Blueberry Peach Crunch Pie
Blueberry Peach Crunch Pie is a great combination of wild blueberries and peaches with our delicious oat and brown sugar[...]
Bumbleberry Pie
Bumbleberry Pie means a whole bunch of blueberries, blackberries, raspberries and strawberries. Another one of Betty's signature pies! Our Bumbleberry pie[...]
Bumbleberry Crunch Pie
Bumbleberry Crunch Pie is a delicious combination of blueberries, blackberries, raspberries and strawberries topped with our famous oatmeal and brown[...]
Caramel Apple Crunch Pie
The Caramel Apple Crunch pie is one of our new additions to our pie family at Betty's. We take our traditional[...]
Betty’s Cheesecake
Betty's Cheesecake is new on the North Shore! We have always had customers ask for cheesecake - so we finally came[...]
Cherry Pie (Double Crust)
Our Cherry Pie is always a Northwoods favorite. Sour Pitted Cherries nestled between two light pastry crusts. Our Cherry Pie[...]
Cherry Crunch Pie
Our Cherry Crunch Pie has elicious Sour Pitted Cherries with an oatmeal and brown sugar topping. Cherry Crunch Pie can[...]
Cherryberry Crunch Pie
Cherryberry Crunch Pie is a combination of Cherries, Blueberries and Raspberries with our delicious oatmeal and brown sugar crunch topping.[...]
Great Lakes Fruit Pie
Try our Great Lakes Fruit Pie. The great taste of Apple, Blueberry, Rhubarb, Strawberry and Raspberry all rolled into one[...]
Maple Walnut Pie
The Maple Walnut Pie is one of our holiday or any day, favorites! Looks exactly like a Pecan pie but[...]
Old Fashioned Apple Pie
The Old Fashioned Apple Pie is our most popular baked fruit pie! We take Granny Smith apples and mix in[...]
Pecan Pie
The Pecan Pie is one of our favorites! What can we say about this Pecan pie... it's FANTASTIC! This tasty[...]
Pumpkin Pie
This delectable pumpkin pie is a great pie for any day but our most popular pie for Thanksgiving and Christmas.[...]
Raspberry Peach Pie
Try our incredible Raspberry Peach Pie. If you love Raspberries and Peaches you are going to love this pie! Our 9" pie tin[...]
Raspberry Rhubarb Pie (double crust)
If you like raspberries and rhubarb you are going to love this Raspberry Rhubarb pie! Our 9" pie tin filled with[...]